Homeschooling vs public school – Is this why parents home school?

Homeschooling vs public school – Is this why parents home school?

‘Is the System failing to teach children how to think?’

 A former new Labour aide who worked closely with Tony Blair, Peter Hyman outlined that there should be a radical shake up of the education system where GCSE”s would be abolished.  It was also highlighted that he was convinced that the government’s direction was wrong.

This was just days before hundreds of thousands of pupils picked up their A-level results and a week before GCSE grades were released; Hyman says the nature of the exam system means that children are not being taught how to think. Hyman, who was a government speechwriter and strategist, is now a deputy head teacher at a London comprehensive. “This [criticism] is aimed at government,” he said. “I blame the system – not schools for doing what they are told.” His plea comes as a poll of company directors today reveals widespread dissatisfaction. One in five directors describes the quality of education in schools as poor or very poor, with half rating it as average.

The Institute of Directors surveyed 1,316 of its members and found that one-third admitted having employees who lacked literacy, numeracy or low-level IT skills, with 70% of those saying it causes a significant problem for their business. The vast majority want much higher priority placed on literacy, numeracy and skills such as public speaking.

In an article in the Observer (16/8/09), Hyman wrote: “There is almost an unspoken deal: we’ll spoon-feed you the required information to pass your exams, if you play by the rules and do your homework on time … GCSE exam results are not a true reflection of the talent of my students … It is time to scrap them.” Is this the reason for homeschooling vs public school?

Hyman calls for a system in which all teenagers take a variety of exams and carry out extended projects between the ages of 14 and 19. A-levels could be incorporated alongside many other options but not as a standalone qualification. Christine Blower, general secretary of the NUT, said: “Standing inside a classroom is very different to standing inside a government department.” Referring to the MP Vernon Coaker, she added: “It will be interesting now that we have a schools minister who has been a teacher.”

A spokeswoman for the Department for Children, Schools and Families said there was already a range of choices for pupils, such as diplomas and apprenticeships. GCSE reform next month would also mean more varied questions.

New Conservative plans for A-levels and GCSEs emerged last night. Some of the proposals being considered include giving more points in school league tables for A-levels achieved in “hard” subjects, such as maths and physics, and fewer points for so-called “soft” subjects such as media studies; and removing vocational qualifications, including the government’s flagship new diploma, from league table rankings because they are “nowhere near as academically demanding”.

Michael Gove, the shadow children’s secretary, told the Sunday Telegraph that Labour’s “meddling and micromanaging of exams” had “dumbed down” the system. Homeschooling vs public school you decide?

 See: http://homeschoolingvspublicschoolfor in depth information on the advantages and disadvantages of homeschooling.